Just a brief comment as to our desire to hedge using the QID and SDS.
Market timing is very difficult, if not impossible (especially in this market). Years ago, no years and years ago, I fancied myself as quite the market technician, scanning the charts and producing divine wisdom of direction and opportunity. Most of the calls were pretty good, and many weren’t. Over time I found my knowledge of technical analysis to be useful, but certainly not the method to produce sustainable returns over time.
Hence why I gravitated to Qauntitative Analysis as the backbone of our research. It is far more objective and has proven to be extremely profitable over time, whereas the market techicians are faced with subjective analysis and as a result spotty returns at best.
That said, when a decision has to be made as to when it is best to put on a protective hedge it involves primarily “feel” and a large dose of technical analysis. The decision must also be made carefully over a period of time so as to not find ourselves “short” when the market decides to be “long”.
This market has been ragged for some months now, going back to October of last year. The pull back in November that left the market barely up on the year was met with a huge rally into December effectively zeroing the decline. Unfortunately since then it has been a horrible tape with the benchmark Russell 3000 down nearly 11% from that point.
Here is the analysis… Market sentiment plays a key role, and while there have been concerns over sub prime, going into the end of 2007 it seemed that most of the problem was factored in. However, it is important to note that since the Fed meeting on December 2007, which netted only a 25bps cut in rates, the market has taken on the fear of recession in addition to financial struggles in the mortgage industry. There is now a significant lack of faith in the Federal Reserve having what it takes to properly steer our economy. This in addition to concerns that the Bush administration may not be acting fast enough to produce a stimulus package.
In a nutshell, sentiment is very poor. Sentiment is also a contrarian indicator, so as it sours it presents a greater likelyhood that an upside reversal is soon to come.
Technically the market has been in a wide trading range going back to about June of 2007. We have been able to capitalize on this volatility which contributed to our 17.5% net return for our Multi-Cap Growth & Value portfolio in 2007.
With the market in a confirmed trading range it becomes difficult to choose where and when to put on a hedge. Most all periods of decline last year were very short and steep. Just since October we have recorded several of our worst one day declines in the history in our 15 years of running money.
Therein lies the problem with hedging this market. First, the declines are steep and last for only a few days, with most of the pain coming on day one. Second, by the time enough information is available to make a determination it is more than likely we will have put in a bottom and reversed. This continues to be an issue today.
The Dow Industrial Average, a reasonable proxy for the market, had a lower trading range, and some considerable support, at 12,700. It has come down and tagged these levels four times in the last 12 months and held. In fact we went through five days of what appeared to be natural base building just a week ago.
At the end of last year we had built up a significant level of profit and held a strong cash position going into the last few days of the year. As a result there did not appear to be any urgent need to add a hedge during the last week or so of tax loss selling of 2007. In fact, the rally into year’s end was seen as a typical reversal and we went back to 100% invested. In hindsight that didn’t help us at all…
Right at the beginning of this year the Dow dropped nearly 4% in three days, leaving no time for retooling and putting on a hedge. The next five days were very volatile with 2%+ moves up, then down, up then down. We perceived this as signaling the end of the bearish declines and were given no reason to expect any further significant down moves.
Of course, the Dow lost over 5% in two days following and finished the week whimpering.
Thankfully our positions in energy and basic materials allowed us to recoup +1% on Friday while the market finished -1/2% lower. A sign that we remain properly positioned in the right stocks in the right sectors.
While there is little to do at this point relative to a panic sell off tomorrow, we will be closely monitoring the markets and your portfolios. I have a mind to be a buyer, but we will see how the day plays out.
Share This
Tags: Fed,
Hedge,
Market,
Multi-Cap,
October,
QID,
Volatility